Skip to content

BATTLE NARRATIVE

With All They Had. Saipan: 8 July 1944

Surely it had to be almost over, thought the Marines of BLT 1-24 as they checked their weapons, choked down their instant coffee and K-ration biscuits, lit up the first cigarette of the day, and climbed out of the twenty-fourth line of foxholes they’d dug since landing on Saipan. Surely, there couldn’t be that many Japanese left on the godforsaken island. Surely, their high command would realize how battered and spent their battalion was. Surely, they would soon be relieved and sent to the rear. The less charitable muttered that the Army should be left to do the mopping up. But here they were, ordered to change directions to the west and assist with cutting off the remnants of the enemy still holed up along the coast near Tanapag. The left flank of the landing force, blunted by the banzai attack the day before, was advancing slowly. Lt. Col. Otto Lessing’s Marines would block the Japanese retreat: the anvil to the 2nd Marine Division’s hammer.

As PFC Edward Curylo put it, “we had to come across the mountain to push the Japs into the sea.”[1] This was easier said than done.

 Reports from the 24th Marines and the 4th Marine Division mention only “moderate” resistance before inevitable success; the NTLF Headquarters opined that “generally, resistance in the 4th MarDiv zone was considered light.”[2] The recollections of the battalion’s veterans, however, tell a very different story – especially when backed up by photographs and casualty reports. In reality, BLT 1-24 experienced some of their toughest fighting when the battle was nearly at an end.

Orders to change direction and head west came as a “pre-dawn surprise” for 1Lt. Frederic A. Stott and the other company commanders of BLT 1-24.[3] Their objective for the day would be the beaches on Saipan’s west coast, designated Orange One and Orange Two in the pre-invasion planning. By this point in the battle, the rifle platoons were so reduced by casualties and illness that weapons platoon men had to fill in; mortarmen like PFC Norman M. Lucas left their 60mm weapon on a company vehicle and fought as riflemen for the day.[4]

Captain Irving Schechters Able Company jumped off with the battalion’s assault at 0630.PFC Tommy Lynchard remembered getting on the move “at first light through thick, jungle-like terrain down the side of a mountain.” The underbrush was so dense that Lynchard almost missed a cave mouth just a few yards away. A small group of Japanese were clustered in the opening, apparently asleep. “We threw grenades and fired our weapons into their heads,” Lynchard said. “I was within twelve feet of four or five, laying sideways to me. I opened up with my BAR and sprayed them all. We moved out before the smoke cleared.” The firing alerted other Japanese in the area, but they had no desire to fight. As Lynchard’s platoon approached a clearing, they could see another group of enemy soldiers running up the bare slope of the next hill. “Our company held up at the base of the hill and fired at the running Japs,” he continued. “Fifteen or twenty altogether tried to escape. Some made it, too.” Schechter ordered his men to hold up; Lynchard gratefully tucked into a can of C-ration hash.[5]

PFC Bernard C. Elissagaray took this flag from a wounded Japanese nurse on D+23.

Baker Company’s route led down a precipitous cave-infested cliff, and patrols went out to search for a manageable descent. First Lieutenant Joseph D. Swoyer led one such group down a twisting path – and directly into the sights of a Japanese sniper, who drilled a Marine through the head. Lanky Lieutenant Swoyer made a good target, but managed to scramble back to safety. He found the rest of his patrol yelling for a corpsman. “Never mind, it’s too late,” said the rattled officer. “He caught it right through the head and he’s gone.”

The men weren’t convinced. “There’s motion out there,” one piped up. Swoyer shook his head. “It’s no use. I checked him, and he’s dead.”

“Not yet,” came a voice from behind. It was “the supposed dead man as he emerged from the woods, his head bloody but under his own power.” An embarrassed Swoyer helped the wounded man to the aid station.[6]

The Japanese holdouts did not expect to survive their encounters with the Marines, and their determination caused casualties and consternation. The Americans, on the other hand, sensed the end of the battle was days away at most, and were loath to take unnecessary risks. PFC Ed Curylo remembered how single snipers delayed or even stopped Baker Company’s advance. “We were held up by one rifle with a flat sound,” he said.[7] “They tied themselves to a tree branch, then they fired away.” Curylo’s sergeant ordered six men to move out, one at a time. Curylo, the seventh, refused. “I’m not going out there alone.”

“You got to,” insisted the sergeant.

“Like hell I got to! Why don’t we send two, maybe confuse him a bit?”

Curylo and a buddy took off together. The sniper fired, missed, and gave away his position; Curylo’s friend brought him down. “One rifle holding up Company B – a hundred and some men,” remarked Curylo. “And it turns out to be a thirteen-year-old kid. I don’t know if he was killed, or if we captured him.”[8]

"Fighting their way through thick brush as well as the Japanese, Marines slowly approach their last objective here in the heart of the Japanese empire." USMC photograph by Sgt. Maurice Garber.

Similar dangers beset Charlie Company. PFC Wesley R. Clinton and his squad cleared out two caves and were working on a third when gunfire erupted. The squad leader came rushing out, one hand clamped around his bleeding arm. He’d caught a glimpse of the Japanese soldier scuttling deeper into the cave, possibly heading for a second exit. Clinton, a twenty-year-old Arkansan skilled with a rifle (his buddies called him “Sergeant York”), was sent down the trail in hopes of catching the fleeing enemy. Unfortunately, the Japanese soldier was well camouflaged. As Clinton stalked down the trail, a gunshot rang out and he fell dead with a bullet in his back.

Minor skirmishes such as these took place throughout the morning as the battalion picked its way across the summit of the mountain range and down the western side to the sea. Several caves and hideouts harbored Chamorros who were only too happy to see the Americans.

Many civilians joyfully emerged from their hideouts as we scrambled down a cave-infested cliff line to the lowest level. Among those whom we released were two priests, several nuns, and many of their Chamorro followers. The Chamorros, though contact with travelers from Guam had been told that the Americans would treat them well. And in addition they had been assured by their priests that the arrival of the Marines would mean their liberation. Their joy gave us some indication of the welcome our brothers-in-arms were receiving at the same time from the people of Normandy.[9]
By the time the battalion reached the burned and blackened cane fields at the base of the cliff, they had nearly fifty civilians in tow.[10] Colonel Lessing ordered a halt to rest his Marines and arrange safe passage for his captives. As the companies caught their breath, two men carrying cameras and notepads came hurrying across the field.
Stanley Troutman

Stanley Troutman wore Marine dungarees, but he was no trained warrior. In civilian life he was a professional photographer for Acme Newspictures, covering homicides, film premieres, sporting events, and Hollywood celebrity scandals from Charlie Chaplain to Errol Flynn. The job was a dream come true, and even came with a draft exemption, but Troutman felt guilty about sitting out the war. In early 1944, Acme asked for volunteers to join the War Picture Pool and Troutman jumped at the chance. He received no military training and was not issued a weapon – just a set of green HBTs and a pair of leather boondockers.

Saipan was Troutman’s first assignment, and the transition was tough. “Being away from my wife and daughter was an adjustment,” he said. “I had to eat C-rations, which tasted like dog food. Adjusting to seeing death was the most difficult.” As a new man in the combat zone, Troutman spent most of his time photographing activities behind the lines.[11]

W. Eugene Smith

Fortunately, Troutman had a brilliant mentor in W. Eugene Smith. A self-taught professional, Smith was well-known to the editors of Newsweek and Life for his artistic photographs, meticulous attention to detail, and his prickly personality. He had already completed a few Pacific assignments for Ziff-Davis, and was on Saipan for Life Magazine. Smith was quite adventuresome, and frequently headed to the fighting or hopped aboard an airplane for aerial views of the fighting. On 7 July, he prevailed upon Troutman to join him on the front lines. They spent a mostly sleepless night with the 2nd Marines with “annoying movement by the Japs,” a near miss by friendly artillery, and “tracers over our head frequently through the night.” In the morning, the two photographers joined the advance to the sea.[12]

The 2nd Marines (attached to the 4th Marine Division for the day) ran into trouble as they descended towards the level ground. “Extremely heavy fire tore the dirt from our shoelaces and cracked and whined over our heads and into some of the Marines’ bodies,” Smith noted. “For over two hours we flattened against the dirt…. We did not even change to a more comfortable position.”[13] Troutman, under direct fire for the first time, thought the experience “something I’ll never forget…. One fellow behind me and one at my side was wounded, so I guess the good Lord was with me.”[14] Tanks finally lent some assistance and the riflemen advanced; the two photographers stretched their cramped limbs and set off in search of new subjects. The next unit in the line happened to be BLT 1-24, and Smith shot a few frames of Marines talking with their captives.

All images in this gallery are © 1944, 2014 The Heirs of W. Eugene Smith, and are published with express permission.

The calm was soon broken. “Jap snipers with rifles and machine guns fired on the group,” wrote Smith, “regardless of the fact that we had Japs with us, or maybe it was for that reason.”[15] The prisoners were hustled away to the rear, and BLT 1-24 quickly redeployed to continue their advance to the coast. Only a few obstacles stood in their way – a farmhouse, some scattered buildings, and a line of trees separating the beach from the fields. The sea was barely a hundred yards away.

They would have to fight like hell to get there.

“The afternoon was far different and costly."

Although we had been practically unopposed in our advance ever since the big attack, it became evident that many of the Jap defenders had not perished in it, but had retired to coastal fortifications. These beaches extending several miles northward from Tanapag were likely locations for a landing effort, and they were honeycombed with an intricate series of trenches, dugouts, and low-lying pillboxes. An observation plane swooped low and dropped a message telling of many enemy soldiers scurrying north along the beach, and just in defilade from us. But we were too close to call for any support from the air or ground.[16]

Tommy Lynchard was still washing the taste of C-rations out of his mouth when his company was ordered forward. “We went in a skirmish line; the platoon on my left set fire to the house,” he recalled. “I was within sixty feet of the burning house when several Japs jumped out of an earth-covered cellar and began throwing hand grenades.” Lynch dropped to one knee and opened fire with his BAR; the Japanese troops jerked and fell backwards as his bullets hit home. The young Mississippian was pleased with his sharpshooting – until a grenade exploded right behind him.

I was stunned, it blew off my helmet and I was at least four feet from my BAR. I was lying on my face with blood running down in my eyes. Frankly, I thought I was dying; I did pray to God to not let me die. I tried to get up, but my back was numb and I couldn't move my legs. I knew as close as I was to the Japs they would finish me off. Five other [Marines] were hit by grenades, I was the only one that couldn't walk or run.

I pushed myself with my hands and dragged my legs to reach my BAR. I didn't worry about my helmet. One or two [Japanese] were still trying to operate, but every time they moved I'd give them a burst of bullets.
Two Marines ran out to drag Lynchard to safety. “One of the guys was a smartmouth and I had never liked him,” Lynchard commented, “but after what he did for me, I could overlook all his faults. I told him, ‘you’ve made me your friend the hard way.'”[17]

Fighting coalesced around the farmhouse. “It was obvious a group of Japanese soldiers had decided to make a stand, and they had several riflemen and at least one machine gun,” said PFC John C. Pope. “They had an open field of fire and held us back for a while.” Pope took cover behind a pile of wood with another Marine who was “playing cowboy” with a helmet on the end of his rifle, trying to draw Japanese fire. The trick backfired. “A few minutes later we got word to get ready to rush the little house,” Pope continued. “[The other Marine] stood straight up and a bullet hit him in the chest. He collapsed and fell across me. I instinctively reached around him and put my hand over a hole in his chest. The blood was surprisingly warm and sticky. It was my first time to have a handful of blood.”[18]

In a cane field not far away, Charlie Company machine gunner PFC Glenn L. Buzzard watched the treeline suspiciously. “The Japs had that fortified,” he recalled. “It was about 20-30 feet of tree growth right down to the water’s edge.” Buzzard began the battle as an ammunition carrier; now he carried his squad’s .30-caliber Browning by a sling around his neck. He was just eighteen years old, but burly and strong enough to fire the machine gun from the hip without a tripod, using an asbestos mitt to keep from burning his hands. “It was a Mickey Mouse thing” – meaning improvised – “but it worked.” His eyes and weapon were fixed on a group of twenty people, apparently civilians, who were hovering right at the edge of the field. “They were women and children, and the men were holding up little babies,” he remembered. “The interpreter was trying to talk to them…. ‘Take it off,’ that’s one of the Japanese phrases they taught us. You had to get them undressed because the men would have grenades stuck under their clothes, and as soon as they got a chance, they would throw it at you.”[19]

PFC Bernard Elissagaray carried this phonetic phrase card on Saipan.
Another big Marine stood up and strode forward, waving his hands in a come-on-over gesture. Buzzard easily recognized his platoon leader, 1Lt. Alexander Santilli, called “The Saint” for his last name and his aspirations to the priesthood. Every fan of college football knew Santilli, who blocked a punt during the 1942 Sugar Bowl and shepherded the Fordham Rams to a 2-0 victory. He was a popular officer, too – one of the original platoon leaders of Dog Company who retained his command when that unit disbanded in March 1944. Lieutenant Santilli had been wounded once already on Saipan, but escaped from the hospital and rejoined his platoon. “He led those men so gallantly that they found themselves treading where fools would normally fear to go,” wrote fellow Fordham scholar Ensign Gerald J. O’Brien. “Al was known and loved by all, even by men who were not in his platoon.”[20] The Saint was not about to stand by and allow innocent civilians to suffer.
Backing Santilli was Sergeant William W. Buller. Like The Saint, Bill Buller was an avid sportsman known around Paterson, New Jersey for his prowess in high school basketball and football. He also shared the lieutenant’s attitudes toward leadership and looking out for his men. “I called him my big brother,” said Buzzard. “Not a whole lot older, but then everyone was older than me. He’d sort of look after me.” Despite their difference in rank, Buller and The Saint were “real good friends.”[21] Their relationship was not unlike that of 1Lt. Philip E. Wood, Jr. and Sergeant Arthur B. Ervin of Able Company – and they now found themselves in a similarly dangerous situation trying to bring civilians to safety.
1Lt. Alexander "Saint" Santilli
Sgt. William W. Buller

The field was dotted with bundles of sugarcane cut and ready for harvest. A sudden shot rang out from one of the piles; The Saint stumbled and sagged to the ground. Seconds later, Buller dropped with a bullet through his face. “There were men underneath,” said Buzzard. “They killed Santilli, and they killed Sergeant Buller. They were shot within seconds of each other.” A cold, murderous rage descended on Glenn Buzzard, and he turned his weapon on the fleeing crowd of civilians. “Neutralized them, let’s say.”[22] Sergeant Miller M. Blue quickly assumed command of the platoon.[23]

"Our Marines advance through one of the many cane fields that dot this island of Saipan on a hunt that will only mean death to the warriors of the Rising Sun." 8 July 1944. Photo by SSgt. Maurice Garber.

A brutal, short-range slugfest quickly developed. “At close range, they opened up with all they had,” said Lieutenant Stott, “stopped half the battalion short of the sea, and inflicted heavy casualties.”[24] As acting company commander, Stott ordered Charlie to assault across the cane field and into the trees. Corporal Joseph G. Jecture, Jr. led his squad into the undergrowth, shooting up every bush and bramble that might conceal an enemy soldier. He doubled back on one particular shrub and “heard an unearthly yell… a Japanese soldier who had pulled the pin from a grenade and, hugging the bomb to his chest, blew himself to eternity.” Pieces of the missile struck Jecture above the eye and on the cheek; he took off for the aid station, but was careful to hold on to his souvenir samurai sword.[25]

Photographers Smith and Troutman hurried over to the farmhouse, shutters clicking, taking mental notes for later captions.

Fighting for the farmhouse, as seen through the lens of Eugene Smith's camera.
All images in this gallery are © 1944, 2014 The Heirs of W. Eugene Smith, and are published with express permission.
Around a farmhouse of resistance, sniper bullets hitting from all directions, we held up for a while. Behind one of the walls in a hole a searching Marine received an exploding grenade in his face that infuriated his buddies so much that they blasted the whole [sic] with grenades, Tommy guns, rifles and finally brought a tank around to blast with its 75. At this point the Marines, who had suffered heavily, found their temper close to the breaking point, but within twenty feet of this scene I saw a Marine giving candy to several women and children prisoners, [they were] 4th Division Marines.[26]
W. Eugene Smith
Photographer, LIFE Magazine

Able Company forced its way into the trees and set about clearing the Japanese fortifications one by one. Corporal Kenneth R. Gray, a former prison guard from Massachusetts, led a demolitions squad against a troublesome stronghold until a bullet punched through his thigh. Nauseated and faint from pain, Gray kept issuing directions and “contributed essentially to the crushing of fanatic Japanese resistance” before passing out.[27] Popular PFC DeWitt L. Dietrich, Jr. carried out a similar assault, “engaging the Japanese in close combat… annihilating many hostile troops.”[28] “Dee,” who observed his nineteenth birthday on 15 June 1944, disappeared during the attack; his body was found three days later with bullet holes in his back. PFC Jack C. Comer was all but obliterated – “nothing was left of him except a scalp with some black hair still on it,” said one of his comrades from the machine gun platoon.[29] Finally, PFC Lester C. Kincaid reached the beach with a radio and contacted the company mortars. Although shot in the chest, he managed to direct a barrage onto the Japanese trenches, “resulting in the rout of the enemy and the attainment of the objective.”[30] Kincaid survived his wounds, and later received the Silver Star Medal.

“We attacked a stretch of woods along a western beach – a hail of fire came from same, killing a large number of guys to say nothing of wounded,” wrote Lieutenant Swoyer of Baker Company. “After sweating it out for a while, we got up to mop up the woods. Three times I went into the woods, and three times nobody followed me but [his runner, PFC Bernard] Novak – I was afraid to take my eyes off the enemy, and yet I had to get the guys to come, too. The third time, I turned to curse my men [and] a Jap jumped out of a hole, whipped back his arm to throw a grenade, but Novak shot him through the heart. The grenade went off in his hand.”[31] Swoyer’s platoon finally broke through to the beach, where Corporal Robert E. Newbury spotted some wounded Marines lying in the open. “Huck” Newbury, already known for his “technical skill and inspiring conduct” over the course of the battle, went out alone to see if he could help. “He paused to see about a wounded friend,” recalled John Pope. “He dropped to his knees, leaned over, and in a matter of seconds he was dead from a sniper bullet. He was lying across his friend’s body when he died.”[32] Newbury would also receive the Silver Star Medal for his “self-sacrificing spirit and unwavering devotion.”[33]

Views of the bitter fighting on Saipan. All photographs are dated 8 July 1944.
Newbury’s wounded buddies wound up at the battalion aid station, where Lt. Richard C. Porter and Lt. (j.g.) William J. Baker were up to their elbows in blood and gore. The two surgeons, graduates of medical schools at the University of Iowa and Harvard, routinely performed emergency operations under difficult conditions – but the influx on the afternoon of 8 July taxed their skills and endurance. Nearly sixty men were treated by the doctors and corpsmen, with wounds ranging from blast concussion and shrapnel scratches to gunshots through the limbs, chest, or face. A group of intelligence scouts were carried in suffering horrific wounds; Sergeant John H. Dearing had his right arm and right leg blown off, while PFC John C. Gale Jr. had his windpipe severed, shrapnel in his head, and a mangled right arm. Gale later told of being evacuated by ox cart – the battalion apparently still had some of these native vehicles in tow – to a railhead where a group of Seabees were running a captured Japanese train on the main line to Charan Kanoa.[34] Two platoon corpsmen were wounded, and Lt (j.g.) Baker was shot through the leg while treating a Marine just behind the front lines. Baker stabilized his patient before tying a compress around his own wound and turning to the next wounded man. He had no intention of leaving when there was so much work to do.[35]
Battalion surgeons William J. Baker and Richard C. Porter.

Finally, the firing died down a bit. Smith snapped a few more images of Marines moving through the smoke-shrouded ruins of the farmhouse, taking shots into wells or holes in the ground, or standing silently by the bodies of dead friends. A Baker Company squad ambled by; one man reached for his canteen and caught the photographer’s attention. Stripped down for combat the way only a veteran could, the Marine still carried a carbine, a .45 caliber pistol, and a long Japanese sword tucked under his arm. His face was striking; sweaty, grimy, unnaturally thin and with piercing blue eyes.

Troutman and Smith knew a good shot when they saw one, and both whipped out their cameras. Troutman caught the Marine in a three-quarters shot, while Smith snapped one directly in profile. The Marine, probably perplexed at the sudden attention, stopped and glared over his shoulder at the photographers. Troutman scribbled Marine drinking water from his canteen in his notepad, and either he or Smith approached the exhausted warrior to ask his name and hometown.[36]

“4th Division Marine PFC T. E. Underwood (24th Bat.) of St. Petersburg Florida,” recorded Smith. “A Portrait of a weary warrior who has been through one of the toughest days of his life. And still at the moment the picture was taken was under fire.”[37]

“It was funny about that,” Ellis later wrote of the picture that would make him famous. “I never had any idea it would get home. I just bent down to take a drink and my picture was taken. The fellow asked me my name and home address. Heavy fighting was going on where the picture was taken.”[38]

Thomas Ellis Underwood, B/1/24th Marines. Photographs by Stanley Troutman and W. Eugene Smith.
For a detailed analysis of these photographs, read
The Weary Warrior.

Finally BLT 1-24 broke through to the beach, stepping over the prostrate bodies of their fallen enemies, even as occasional gunshots or suicide grenade blasts reverberated through the undergrowth. The final hundred-yard push had been one of the hardest of the entire campaign. “The tenacity with which they defended these last positions gave a clear indication of why the western coastal advance had temporarily bogged down,” reflected Lieutenant Stott. “Ours was a comparatively small area, and with the aid of rapid firing tanks, the remainder of the battalion sector was cleared out. But it was very depressing to have suffered so heavily at a time when we thought the organized opposition practically ended.”[39]

Eugene Smith still had a few exposures left. Seeing one Marine gazing out to sea, he snapped a beautiful silhouette shot. “And the Marines did crash through to the beach as the sun dropped into the ocean on the western side of the island,” he wrote. “And hundreds of dead Japs were given a farewell spotlight by the last rays of the sun.”[40]

All images in this gallery are © 1944, 2014 The Heirs of W. Eugene Smith, and are published with express permission.

The Word spread down through the ranks like wildfire. Someone had it on good authority from one of the Navajo code talkers that the island was secure. The exhausted Marines mustered as much enthusiasm as they could for the news; after all, rumors were rife. Early in the battle, most Marines firmly believed that Russia had declared war on Japan; later, some told tales that Amelia Earhart’s belongings had been found in a jail in Garapan.[41] Yet this one seemed true. The battalion had reached almost the very northern end of the island; this last attack must have been the final pocket. The battle must be over.

PFC Robert E. Tierney had just begun to process this information when he was shot. A sniper’s bullet tore into his back, passed through his ribs, and shattered his left arm. The company’s reaction was swift and terrible for the lone Japanese gunman, swift and fortunate for the badly wounded boy from Birnamwood.

I was evacuated to the hospital ship USS Samaritan. We were told that we were heading to New Caledonia to fleet hospital #105 because all of the hospitals in Hawaii and the west coast of the US were filled. When I was taken aboard ship, two nurses looked at me and asked if it would be OK to take my picture. When we landed, we shaved all the hair off our heads. After 26 days my black hair grew back, but I had a red beard. I was still wearing the same dungarees I landed in and they were filthy and tattered – I must have been a sight.

“My left arm was taped to a board,” Tierney continued. “During my 25 days on the island, I lost over 30 pounds. There were about 1200 wounded Marines on board the ship. The next morning [July 9] I heard the bugler playing taps. A nurse informed me that 10 Marines had died overnight and the ceremony on deck was for burials at sea. My surgery was scheduled for 0200 the following morning. Up to that time the doctors had been operating for 72 hours with just short breaks.​”

Bob Tierney was on the long trip home – and it began with a coincidence; the doctor operating on his arm was a family friend from back in Wisconsin. At New Caledonia, he received his Purple Heart medal from Bob Hope himself; luckily a camera was on hand to capture “a whole roll of film of [actress Carol Landis] and various friends.” The Japanese bullet cost Tierney nearly four inches of bone from his left arm; a botched operation and administrative red tape would harry him for years. He did not return to “the mainstream” until August 1950 – seven years and five months after enlisting.[42]

That night, BLT 1-24 bivouacked on the battlefield. The end of the campaign was indeed nigh – but there would be one final drama in the fight for Saipan. For those who were there, the events at Marpi Point on 9 July 1944 would dominate their stories and haunt their memories for the remainder of their lives.

Bob Tierney recovering from his Saipan wounds.

Previous Day

Table Of Contents

Next Day

Footnotes

[1] Edward Curylo, oral history interview conducted by Brian Louwers (4 December 2013), Edward Curylo Collection (AFC/2001/001/94115), Veterans History Project, American Folklife Center, Library of Congress.

[2] Northern Troops Landing Force Mailbrief 00187-3, 8 July 1944.

[3] Frederic A. Stott, “Saipan Under Fire” (Andover: Frederic Stott, 1945), 18.

[4] Norman M. Lucas Collection (AFC/2001/001/30436), Veterans History Project, American Folklife Center, Library of Congress.

[5] Tommy Lynchard, unpublished personal papers. Author’s collection.

[6] Stott, 19. While not known for certain, the wounded man was very likely Private Marwood B. Smith, who had only joined Baker Company the previous week. Smith, who suffered a gunshot wound in the head on 8 July 1944, was evacuated for treatment and at first appeared to make a good recovery. Unfortunately, he developed a cerebral abscess while hospitalized in Noumea, and died on 11 August 1944. This incident, while not among Swoyer’s best moments, evidently did little to sour his reputation; he received two Bronze Stars and two Purple Hearts, and ended the war as the commanding officer of Baker Company.

[7] The distinctive sound of the Japanese Arisaka rifle was unusually hard to pinpoint.

[8] Curylo interview.

[9] Stott, 19.

[10] “Action Report: First Battalion, 24th Marines Record of Events, 15 June – 9 July 1944″ (24 August 1944). Hereafter BLT 1-24 Report.

[11] Stanley Troutman, interview with the author, 2014. Troutman was assigned first to the Navy, where correspondents carried rank equivalent to a Lieutenant Commander. He followed the Marines into action on Saipan, Tinian, Guam, and Peleliu.

[12] W. Eugene Smith, “Captions: Saipan – Final Days of Invasion,” July 1944. Reproduced by W. Eugene Smith Archive, Center for Creative Photography University of Arizona, Tucson, 2014.

[13] Ibid.

[14] Stanley Troutman, personal letter dated 11 July 1944. Courtesy Gayle Rindge.

[15] Smith, “Captions: Saipan”

[16] Stott, 19.

[17] Lynchard papers.

[18] John C. Pope, Angel On My Shoulder, Kindle eBook. Pope identifies the other Marine as “Bowman”; PFC Harold A. Bowman served with C/1/24th Marines, but there is no indication that he was wounded on Saipan. (Bowman did suffer two wounds – including a shot through the chest – in later battles.)

[19] Glenn Buzzard in Gail Chatfield, By Dammit, We’re Marines! (San Diego: Methvin Publishing, 2008), 63.

[20] Jack Cuddy, “Alex Santilli, Who Wouldn’t Stay ‘Benched,’ Is Killed At Saipan,” The Republican and Herald (Pottsville, PA) 18 August 1944.

[21] Chatfield, 63. Buzzard lied about his age to enlist at the age of sixteen; his physical stature helped pull off the ruse.

[22] Ibid.

[23] This was the second time Sergeant Blue took charge of a leaderless platoon; he received the Silver Star Medal for his actions.

[24] Stott,19.

[25] “Marine Corporal Brings Back to Naugatuck Tale of Battles With The Japs.” Naugatuck Daily News, December 29, 1944. Jecture picked up the sword during a banzai attack; his hometown newspaper rather breathlessly described the souvenir as “a beautiful Japanese officer’s sword that on the west coast has a standardized value of $300. The sword has a two-handed grip and is razor sharp.”

[26] Smith, “Captions: Saipan”

[27] Kenneth Russell Gray., Official Military Personnel File (OMPF), Records of the Office of the Quartermaster General, Washington National Records Center, Suitland, MD.

[28] “Colwyn Parents Awarded Medal,” The Delaware County Times 2 July 1945.

[29] Wallace Duncan, interview with the author, 2009. Duncan stated that Comer was hit by an artillery shell, however Duncan had been wounded and evacuated two days prior. Official cause of death was “bullet wounds.” Comer was listed as “remains not recovered” for some time before identification could be made by Graves Registration.

[30] Lester C. Kincaid, citation for Silver Star Medal, Headquarters USMC. Available online

[31] Joseph D. Swoyer, personal letter to Joseph & Alice Swoyer, 1 May 1945. Collection of Andy Swoyer.

[32] Pope, Angel On My Shoulder.

[33] Robert E. Newbury. citation for Silver Star Medal, Headquarters USMC. Available online

[34] “Local Saipan Hero Arrives In Phila., Jack Gale Tells Hair-Raising Story,” The Greenbelt Cooperator (Greenbelt, MD) 8 September 1944. Gale had previously escaped serious injury when an anti-tank shell detonated at Camp Pendleton, and made a full recovery. Unfortunately, the remnants of his arm turned gangrenous and were later amputated.

[35] Lieutenant Baker received the Silver Star Medal for gallantry on 8 July 1944. He refused evacuation and served in the sick bay until laid low by disease at the very end of the month.

[36] Troutman 2014 interview. “Eugene and I would have personally talked to the Marine to get his name, rank, and hometown,” clarified Troutman. Photographers went to great lengths to ensure accuracy in identifying individuals whenever possible—it made for good copy for the newspapers, and was a mark of their journalistic integrity. In civilian life, a botched caption could cost a photographer his job.

[37] Smith, “Captions: Saipan”

[38] “Marines Doing Quick Job Routing Japs In Pacific, But Pause For Souvenirs,” The St. Petersburg Times, 17 September 1944.

[39] Stott, 19.

[40] Smith, “Captions: Saipan”

[41] Stott related the Russia rumor (“Saipan Under Fire,” 4.) The Earhart story has captivated audiences since the battle, and may have a grain of truth behind it. Bob Williams recalled hearing the rumors himself: “Scuttlebutt, rumors get to flying. I don’t know where it started, but there was a little town called Garapan north of where we landed. Rumors came through that a white woman was found in Garapan. The next thing you know, the rumor says ‘Amelia Earhart.’ You’ve heard all kinds of rumors about her. Something must have started it, they must have found someone. It’s just one of those weird things.”

[42] Robert E. Tierney, “My Marine Corps Experience,” unpublished memoir dated 10 January 2013.

Battalion Daily Report

Casualties, Evacuations, Joinings & Transfers
0

KIA/DOW

0

WIA & EVAC*

0

SICK

0

JOINED

0

TRANSFERRED

0

STRENGTH

Out of an original landing strength of 888 officers and men.
* Does not include minor wounds not requiring evacuation from the line.
NameCompanyRankRoleChangeCauseDisposition
Baker, William JessaminHeadquartersLieutenant (j.g.)Assistant SurgeonWounded In ActionGunshot, legNot evacuated
Bartels, Ronald PaulAblePFCMortarmanReturned To DutyFrom hospitalTo Able Company
Brewer, Dawson JamesCharliePFCMachine GunnerWounded In ActionUnknown (slight)Evacuated, destination unknown
Buller, William WarrenCharlieSergeantMG Platoon NCOKilled In ActionGunshot, faceRemoved for burial
Burns, Elmo ArthurCharliePlatoon Sergeant1 Platoon NCOReturned To DutyFrom hospitalTo Charlie Company
Burton, Charles FilmoreCharliePFCMessengerKilled In ActionGunshot, chestRemoved for burial
Ciecierski, Frank WalterCharlieCorporalMG Squad LeaderSickUnknownEvacuated, destination unknown
Clinton, Wesley ReginaldCharliePFCRiflemanKilled In ActionGunshot, backRemoved for burial
Comer, Jack CalvinAblePFCMachine GunnerKilled In ActionGunshot woundsRemoved for burial
Comer, William Walter Jr.AbleSergeantSquad LeaderWounded In ActionShrapnel, right leg & groinEvacuated, destination unknown
Conway, Norman LesterCharlieCorporalSquad LeaderSickUnknownEvacuated, destination unknown
Cusimano, Michael SalvatoreCharliePFCMachine GunnerSickUnknownEvacuated, destination unknown
Czerweic, Charles PeterCharlieSergeantMG Section LeaderWounded In ActionUnknown (slight)Evacuated, destination unknown
Davis, Ray Henry Jr.HeadquartersPFCScoutWounded In ActionUnknown (slight)Not evacuated
Dearing, John HenryHeadquartersSergeantIntelligence NCOWounded In ActionAmputation, right arm & legEvacuated to USS Relief
Dietrich, DeWitt Landre Jr.AblePFCBARmanKilled In ActionGunshot, backRemoved for burial
Estergall, Albert JamesBakerSergeantGuide, 2 PlatoonWounded In ActionUnknown (slight)Not evacuated
Fagan, Philip EdwinCharlieCorporalSquad LeaderWounded In ActionUnknown (slight)Not evacuated
Fields, James ClayAblePrivateRiflemanWounded In ActionGunshot, chestEvacuated to USS Relief
Fitzgerald, Paul CliffordCharlieCorporalSquad LeaderSickUnknownEvacuated, destination unknown
Freeman, James WalterAblePFCBARmanWounded In ActionShrapnel, both legsEvacuated to USS Relief
Gale, John Carl Jr.HeadquartersPFCScoutWounded In ActionAmputation, left armEvacuated, destination unknown
Gaminde, Pedro Jr.BakerPFCRiflemanWounded In ActionUnknown (slight)Evacuated, destination unknown
Gilboy, John ArthurBakerPrivateRiflemanSickUnknownEvacuated, destination unknown
Gonsowski, Vincent FrankCharlieCorporalSquad LeaderSickUnknownEvacuated, destination unknown
Gray, Kenneth RussellAbleCorporalSquad LeaderWounded In ActionGunshot, left thighEvacuated to USS Cambria
Harris, Robert NelsonAblePFCBARmanWounded In ActionUnknown (slight)Evacuated, destination unknown
Hicks, James RobertHeadquartersCorporalIntelligence NCOWounded In ActionShrapnel, body & limbsEvacuated, destination unknown
Holden, John WilliamCharliePrivateRiflemanKilled In ActionGunshot woundsRemoved for burial
Jecture, Joseph Gabriel Jr.CharlieCorporalSquad LeaderWounded In ActionGrenade shrapnel, faceEvacuated, destination unknown
Jiracek, Emil George Jr.CharliePFCMortarmanWounded In ActionUnknown (slight)Evacuated, destination unknown
Johnson, Tom LawrenceAblePFCRiflemanWounded In ActionGunshot, left footEvacuated, destination unknown
Jones, Junior ErvingAblePFCRiflemanWounded In ActionGunshot, right legEvacuated, destination unknown
Jordan, Hayword LouieCharliePFCBARmanWounded In ActionUnknown (slight)Evacuated, destination unknown
Kincaid, Lester ClarksonAbleCorporalAmmo NCOWounded In ActionGunshot, chestEvacuated, destination unknown
Klauss, Vermoine VertelleHeadquartersPhM2cCorpsmanWounded In ActionUnknown (slight)Evacuated, destination unknown
Klohs, Edwin EarnestHeadquartersCorporalOperations ClerkWounded In ActionUnknown (slight)Evacuated, destination unknown
Leonard, Walter WilliamHeadquartersHA1cCorpsmanWounded In ActionUnknown (slight)Evacuated, destination unknown
Loughrey, John JosephCharlieSecond LieutenantLeader, 1 PlatoonWounded In ActionUnknown (slight)Not evacuated
Loutzenhiser, William PaulAblePFCMessengerWounded In ActionUnknown (slight)Evacuated, destination unknown
Luckage, Michael RichardHeadquartersPrivateRiflemanWounded In ActionUnknown (slight)Evacuated, destination unknown
Lynchard, TommyAblePFCBARmanWounded In ActionMultiple shrapnel woundsEvacuated, destination unknown
Marshall, GlennAblePFCBARmanWounded In ActionBlast concussionEvacuated, destination unknown
McBride, Parker SamuelAblePlatoon Sergeant2 Platoon NCOWounded In ActionGunshot, right hand & thighEvacuated, destination unknown
Moore, J. S.BakerPFCBARmanKilled In ActionMultiple woundsRemoved for burial
Neiderlander, Edward JosephHeadquartersCorporalClerkSickUnknownEvacuated, destination unknown
Newbury, Robert EdwardBakerCorporalSquad LeaderKilled In ActionGunshot woundsRemoved for burial
Pappas, Gust AlexanderAblePFCBARmanReturned To DutyFrom hospitalTo Able Company
Pentland, Jack DouglasBakerPFCBARmanWounded In ActionGunshot, left ankleEvacuated, destination unknown
Pounders, Robert Floyd JrBakerPFCBARmanReturned To DutyFrom hospitalTo Baker Company
Queen, Charles EdwinBakerPrivateAmmo CarrierKilled In ActionGunshot, backRemoved for burial
Quinn, William JosephAbleCorporalSquad LeaderWounded In ActionShrapnel, left thighEvacuated to USS Relief
Reeves, Robert WaydeCharliePFCRiflemanSickUnknownEvacuated, destination unknown
Reilly, John JamesHeadquartersPFCMortarmanReturned To DutyFrom hospitalTo HQ Company
Rogers, James GeorgeBakerPFCFire Team LeaderKilled In ActionGunshot, chestRemoved for burial
Sander, StanleyCharlieCorporalSquad LeaderWounded In ActionShrapnel, upper left armNot evacuated
Santilli, AlexanderCharlieFirst LieutenantLeader, MG PlatoonKilled In ActionGunshot woundsRemoved for burial
Sayers, Jack TarletonAbleSergeantSquad LeaderWounded In ActionGunshot, left chestEvacuated, destination unknown
Seitz, Robert FredBakerPFCBARmanWounded In ActionUnknown (slight)Evacuated, destination unknown
Sempert, William EdwardBakerPFCMachine GunnerWounded In ActionUnknown (slight)Evacuated, destination unknown
Sheptock, StephenCharlieSergeantGuide, 1 PlatoonWounded In ActionGunshot, left chestEvacuated, destination unknown
Sherrill, Robert EugeneHeadquartersPFCMessengerWounded In ActionUnknown (slight)Not evacuated
Smith, Marwood BaldwinBakerPrivateRiflemanWounded In Action (Fatal)Gunshot, headEvacuated, destination unknown
Stevens, JosephAbleFirst LieutenantLeader, MG PlatoonWounded In ActionGunshot, left forearmEvacuated, destination unknown
Stringer, Charlie LemmonsCharliePrivateRiflemanWounded In ActionUnknown (slight)Evacuated, destination unknown
Sullivan, LaVerne ElliottBakerPFCAmmo CarrierWounded In ActionGunshot, left thighEvacuated, destination unknown
Thomas, Keith WilliamAblePFCAmmo CarrierWounded In ActionGunshot, left handEvacuated, destination unknown
Tierney, Robert EdwardAblePFCBARmanWounded In ActionGunshot, left armEvacuated, destination unknown
Valley, Phillip Jr.AblePFCRiflemanWounded In ActionGunshot, abdomenEvacuated, destination unknown
Wallace, Jesse CalvinCharliePFCBARmanWounded In ActionUnknown (serious)Evacuated, destination unknown
Weber, CarlBakerPFCRiflemanWounded In ActionGunshot, right shoulder & chestEvacuated, destination unknown
Whitehead, Morris SextonCharliePFCBARmanWounded In ActionGunshot, face & neckEvacuated, destination unknown

Taps

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Welcome aboard! If you're looking for www.1stbattalion24thmarines.com – you're in the right place.

We're still working to get all the content from the old site to the new server, so if you can't find what you're looking for, it's probably in the queue. Check out the "NEWS" tab for the latest updates.

Thanks,
Geoffrey

X